Christmas beer test 2026: five Christmas beers from Alko, rated with stars
Which Christmas beer is worth carrying home to go with the ham, the casseroles and the gingerbread, and which familiar name is just fine? Five beers, stars and straight reasons.
It is a little past three, and it is already dark outside. The sweet, slightly caramelly smell of swede casserole drifts from the oven, and the shelves at Alko have changed their colours to red, gold and Santa hats. I went through the Christmas beers like a buddy pushing a shopping cart next to you and telling you straight what to pick up. There is a winner at the end, and it is an easy choice.
I weighed the beer itself: aroma, mouthfeel, the balance of sweetness and bitterness, aftertaste and whether the beer is cleanly brewed. Just as important was whether the bottle delivers what its own style and the winter promise. A bock is measured as a bock and a spiced Belgian as a spiced Belgian. Food tips are included so that each bottle finds its place at the table. The stars are my own verdict.
Gouden Carolus Christmas
Brouwerij Het Anker · 10 % · 0.75 l
The Christmas beer from the old Mechelen brewery pulls off a rare trick: the spices are there, but they do not shout. In the glass it is dark mahogany. The aroma has dried plum, raisin, liquorice and a warm spice cupboard. The body is full-bodied but not sticky, and the warmth of ten percent melts into caramel without prickling. The aftertaste goes on for a long time and dries out slightly at the end. This is a slow beer, not a thirst-quencher. The 75 cl bottle is made for sharing over a cheese board, and the plum jam in a joulutorttu (Finnish Christmas tart) finds a relative in it.
Illustration: AI
Aecht Schlenkerla Eiche
Heller-Trum · 8 % · 0.5 l
Bamberg's famous smoked beer house usually smokes its malt with beech. For this winter beer it uses oak, and you can taste the difference. The smoke is softer and rounder: less bacon, more embers. Beneath it is the full-bodied, slightly sweet malt body of a doppelbock, which carries the smoke and smooths out the eight percent. For someone not used to smoked beer the first sip can be confusing, but by the third many are already reaching for the bottle. The fifth star is missing because the smoke ends up covering everything else, and a second bottle already feels heavy. It is at its best with smoked fish from the fish table.
Illustration: AI
Ayinger Winterbock
Brauerei Aying · 6.7 % · 0.5 l
Aying's winter bock is at heart a clean lager, which is why its malt character tastes so bright. The deep amber beer has bread crust, honey and roasted nuts, and you do not miss any fruitiness from the yeast. The body is round, but the finish dries off neatly, so even a second glass does not feel heavy. It is the lightest beer in the test and the most flexible bottle at the dinner table. It offers no surprises, but it does its job flawlessly. A mustard-glazed Christmas ham and this bock are made for the same evening.
Illustration: AI
Ridgeway Very Bad Elf can
Ridgeway · 7.5 % · 0.44 l
The Very Bad Elf series is a fun idea from an English small brewery, but above all Very Bad Elf is a traditional English strong ale. It is copper-coloured and toffee-like, with marmalade-like fruit and an earthy British hops bitterness. The beer aims for drinkability rather than depth: the glass empties easily, but there is little to remember afterwards. It works well with the caramel notes of the casseroles.
Illustration: AI
Delirium Christmas
Brouwerij L.Huyghe · 10 % · 0.33 l
The Christmas version of the pink elephant is a familiar name that is perfectly nice but no more. The red-brown beer has candied fruit and plenty of sweetness, and the alcohol warms the throat a little too visibly. The small bottle is enough to go with gingerbread.
Illustration: AI
Test awards
Test winner: Gouden Carolus Christmas is spicy, deep and balanced, exactly what a Christmas beer should be.
Best with ham: Ayinger Winterbock brings clean malt and a dry finish alongside the ham.
Best with casseroles: Ridgeway Very Bad Elf can meets the sweetness of swede and carrot casserole with its toffee.
Best for the fish table: Aecht Schlenkerla Eiche and smoked fish seem to have known each other forever.
Best with joulutorttu tarts and cheeses: Gouden Carolus Christmas is at home next to plum jam and a cheese board.
The curious pick: Aecht Schlenkerla Eiche, if you have never tasted oak-smoked malt.
Serve the strong Belgians and the English ale at about 10–12 degrees in a tulip or stemmed glass, so the fruit and spices come through. Bocks and smoked beers taste best at 8–10 degrees, so take them out of the fridge a moment before pouring.
Choose your store to see prices and whether the bottles are on the shelf.
Q&A
Which beer won the Christmas beer test?
Gouden Carolus Christmas got five stars. Its spices are restrained, with flavours of dried plum, raisin and liquorice, the body is full-bodied and the aftertaste long.
Which Christmas beer goes with the Christmas ham?
Ayinger Winterbock. Its clean, bready malt flavour and dry finish suit a mustard-glazed ham.
Which beer goes with the Christmas fish table?
Aecht Schlenkerla Eiche. The smoke of its soft, oak-smoked malt finds its match in the smoked fish on the fish table.
At what temperature should Christmas beer be served?
Strong Belgians and the English ale at about 10–12 degrees in a tulip or stemmed glass, bocks and smoked beers at 8–10 degrees.
AI writer on beer, with a soft spot for hops, yeast and small breweries. Happy to explain why an IPA tastes the way it does, without drowning you in jargon.
Articles and images are AI-generated. The writers are characters, not real people.